Books Like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder: 9 YA Picks Plus a New One

Loved A Good Girl's Guide to Murder? These YA mysteries match what hooked you, from cold cases to unreliable narrators to ensemble suspects.

Illustration of a girl with long blond hair and glasses holding a pink phone, from Accidental Tribes

Looking for books like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder? Your next reads are Truly Devious, The Cheerleaders, Promise Boys, We Were Liars, I Killed Zoe Spanos, The Reappearance of Rachel Price, One of Us Is Lying, The Inheritance Games, and The Agathas. Each one delivers a specific thing that hooked you on Holly Jackson’s book, whether that was Pip’s obsessive evidence-building, a town covering up its own mess, or the moment you realized the adults were the problem all along.

We’ve grouped these YA mysteries by the quality that hooked you: the school secret, the narrator you can’t fully trust, or the group where everyone is hiding something. We’ve also flagged which books start a series, so you don’t accidentally commit to a trilogy expecting a one-night read. And if you want something newer, one illustrated YA mystery from this year gets its own section at the end.

Key takeaways

  • Cold-case fans: Start with Truly Devious or The Cheerleaders for the closest investigation energy.
  • Unreliable narrator fans: We Were Liars and I Killed Zoe Spanos will mess with your head in the best way.
  • Ensemble thriller fans: One of Us Is Lying and The Inheritance Games are the most binge-worthy picks here.
  • Series vs. standalone: Several picks wrap up in one book, while Truly Devious, One of Us Is Lying, The Inheritance Games, and The Agathas continue in sequels.
  • Content check: Several of these books deal with death, grief, and violence, so check content notes before handing them to younger teens.

School secrets and cold-case investigations

These three books recreate the feeling of a teen going where she isn’t supposed to, finding a death someone wants buried, and cracking the case one contradiction at a time.

Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson

This is the closest structural match on the list. Stevie Bell enrolls at Ellingham Academy to investigate a famous 1936 kidnapping, and then a student dies, pulling the past and present into the same case. Alternating timelines, an isolated boarding-school suspect pool, and a research-driven heroine all echo Pip’s story.

Good to know: it’s the first book in a series, and the main mystery carries across the first three books, so plan for the whole arc.

The Cheerleaders by Kara Thomas

Five cheerleaders died in one year in Sunnybrook, including Monica’s sister. Years later, Monica starts noticing that the official story doesn’t add up. If your favorite part of Pip’s story was realizing the police got it wrong, this is your pick. It’s a standalone, so all the answers land in one book.

Promise Boys by Nick Brooks

Three teen narrators, one murdered principal, and a system that wants the case closed fast. Promise Boys adds real-world stakes around school discipline and who gets blamed when institutions protect themselves instead of their students.

Unreliable narrators you can’t quite trust

Part of the tension in Pip’s investigation was the sense that even her understanding of events might be incomplete. These books are built around that feeling.

We Were Liars by E. Lockhart

Atmospheric, literary, and devastating. The tone is slower and dreamier than Holly Jackson’s, but the core is the same: a narrator who can’t give you the full truth, and a reveal that sends you back through every chapter in your head. The story stands on its own, and there’s a prequel if you want more.

I Killed Zoe Spanos by Kit Frick

A teen confesses to a death she doesn’t remember causing, and the truth has to be pieced together. Dual timelines and competing accounts make this one of the more ambiguous YA whodunits out there. It’s a standalone.

The Reappearance of Rachel Price by Holly Jackson

Not ready to leave Holly Jackson behind? Bel’s mother vanished when Bel was a baby, and while her family is filming a true crime documentary about it, her mother reappears. The investigative tension feels very familiar in the best way, and it’s a standalone.

Ensemble mysteries with a group of suspects

Some readers were hooked as much by the social dynamics as the mystery: shifting alliances, one secret exposing another, and trust collapsing in real time.

One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus

Five students walk into detention, one dies, and the remaining four all become suspects with secrets to protect. Rotating points of view and steady reveals make this a go-to readalike for librarians. It starts a series, but each book centers on a different mystery, so the commitment is lighter than it sounds.

The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

A teen inherits a billionaire’s fortune with no explanation, and a house full of suspects, hidden clues, and untrustworthy relatives stands between her and the truth. The puzzle-solving is turned up higher here than anywhere else on the list. It’s the first in a series, and it rewards reading in order.

The Agathas by Kathleen Glasgow and Liz Lawson

Two unlikely partners, one missing classmate, and small-town politics that make every suspect seem plausible. The main mystery wraps up in the first book, and the series continues with a sequel.

A newer pick for fans who want something different

Accidental Tribes by C.S. Pascoal, published by Prospera Books in 2026, earns its spot here. Eight defiant teens are sent to a forgotten classroom called Solitaria, where they uncover an unsolved death, stolen funds, and a cover-up the school wants buried. AI misuse, hacked systems, viral humiliation, and anonymous accounts are all part of the story.

It’s an illustrated YA mystery, which makes it a great pick for a reluctant reader who isn’t ready for a 400-page thriller. It has been praised by the Midwest Book Review, its Teen Advance Reader Council, and educators. You can read the first chapters free, and teachers and librarians can find classroom resources for discussions about AI misuse and digital manipulation.

Series or standalone: what to know before you commit

The standalones on this list are The Cheerleaders, Promise Boys, I Killed Zoe Spanos, and The Reappearance of Rachel Price. We Were Liars also tells a complete story in one book.

For the series picks:

  • Truly Devious has the longest investigative arc here, and the mystery carries directly across books, so read in order.
  • One of Us Is Lying keeps the social-thriller energy going, though each book shifts to a new central mystery.
  • The Inheritance Games rewards the full commitment most if puzzles are your favorite part.

Jumping into book two of any series will spoil the first, so start at the beginning.

Your next read is waiting

If A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder wrecked you in the best way, every book here gives you something specific to chase. Cold-case fans should start with Truly Devious or The Cheerleaders. Readers who can’t trust anyone, including the narrator, should go straight to We Were Liars or I Killed Zoe Spanos. Ensemble fans need One of Us Is Lying, and puzzle lovers should line up The Inheritance Games next. For more ideas, Book Riot and the Westport Library both keep readalike lists.

And if you want a fast, illustrated mystery with eight distinct teens and a school cover-up, start reading Accidental Tribes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are any of these books better for older teens?

Several deal with death, grief, violence, and intense reveals. The Cheerleaders in particular covers heavy material, so check content notes before handing these to younger teens.

Do any of these books include resources for teachers or librarians?

Yes. Accidental Tribes offers free classroom and library resources for discussions about AI misuse and digital manipulation, and the first chapters are free to preview online.